Tuesday, 16 April 2024

David Rose On Qualifiers

Qualifiers specify a Thing, so the semantic probe (from ‘above’) is which or whose Thing?
Which year?
The year [1920]

Which city?
The city [of Rome]
and again at 12:45:
Focus attends to some aspect of the Thing – a facet, part, class or group. The Thing doesn't specify the Focus. Focus is realised by an embedded nom gp, usually linked to the nom gp by the structure marker ‘of’.

[green leaves of] the trees, [some historic buildings of] Rome

Qualifier is realised by an embedded clause or prep phrase

In The city [of Rome], ‘of’ is a preposition, specifying which city.

Blogger Comments:


[1] To be clear, the Deictic, Numerative, Epithet, Classifier all serve to characterise the Thing (Halliday & Matthiessen 2014: 382), so the probe 'Which Thing?' does not uniquely identify a Qualifier. For example,

  • which year? this year: Deictic
  • which year? the third year: Numerative
  • which year? a good year: Epithet
  • which year? a leap year: Classifier
Likewise

  • which city? her city: Deictic
  • which city? the next city: Numerative
  • which city? a polluted city: Epithet
  • which citythe eternal city: Classifier

[2] To be clear, 'Focus' is Martin's use of a textual concept to rebrand embedded experiential elements preceding the Thing in a nominal group.

[3] This should go without saying, since it is the Thing that is characterised in a nominal group.

[4] To be clear, these are simply nominal groups with Qualifiers:
  • green leaves [of the trees]
  • some historic buildings [of Rome]
[of the trees] qualifies leaves in terms of type, [of Rome] qualifies buildings in terms of location.

[5] Trivially, Qualifier is also realised by an embedded adverbial group, as in
  • some 4,000 million years [ago]

[6] Clearly, the structure-marking preposition of does not specify which city:
  • which city? of.

No comments: